Case Study: Superb Magazine Limited – Investment Proposal (summary)

A new UK nationally distributed monthly magazine for young adults and families interested in biking and travelling is proposed, with a cover price of £2.50 and sales through major chains and national outlets. An experienced entrepreneur leads the management team, supported by media advertising and distribution companies. £25,000 equity has been raised and a two-year bank loan of £60,000 is being negotiated to finance production and trading. A further £100,000 of risk capital is expected for start-up promotion, for which a 31.25% share is offered with projected repayment at the end of year three; the investment may be structured under the Enterprise Investment Scheme. Turnover is forecast to exceed £1 million by year four, and publication in Asia is being researched. The case includes projected financial information for analysis.

Questions

As a bank lending officer, consider the information in the case study and carry out an in-depth analysis using the concepts covered in the module:

  1. Is a loan of £60,000 a good risk proposition? [30 marks]
  2. Is it likely that the project will run short of finance and the bank be asked for additional funding? [23 marks]
  3. How easily will repayment be achieved? [22 marks]
  4. What security should the bank request? [13 marks]
  5. Report presentation and research demonstrating a review of theory and application of techniques. [12 marks]
dissertation structure

Want Help Structuring Your Answers

✔ Native UK Experts

✔ All Subjects Covered

✔ Professional Guidance

Accounting Assignment Help

Experts Answer on Above Questions on Accounting

Loan of £60000 a good risk proposition?

From the bank point of view, the loan of £60000 presents a moderate to high risk because Superb Magazine Limited is relatively a new business without having much sales history. Experience of the management is also not very high which poses significant operational risk, while the market potential is also uncertain as the actual demand from the youth adults and families is unclear. The initial contribution of £25000 indicates a commitment from the management but it is relatively small in relation to the proposed borrowing and startup requirements. The business has a significant dependence on external investment as an additional £100000 risk capital investment is needed, and without it, the business may struggle to finance its promotion and market awareness activities.
It is therefore recommended that the bank should not approve the loan unconditionally, and the approval should depend on securing £100000 investment.

Likelihood of project running short of finance and need for additional funding

There is a significant possibility that the business may face gas shortages because the publishing of magazine requires significant upfront expenditure. For example, production costs like printing, editorial salaries, photography and distribution should be paid for any revenue generated. The promotional expenses depend on securing £100000 investment which could create the issue of funding gap. The revenue is also delayed because the retailers and distributors make payment after selling the magazines which creates a time gap. The business also has to face expansion costs as researching Asian publications would require the business to incur additional marketing, licensing and distribution expenses.
It is therefore essential for the bank to ask for a monthly cash flow statement for at least the first 12 months.

How easily will the repayment be achieved

The business would face significant challenges in making repayment as the loan must be repaid in two years but the business forecast indicates that the turnover would be substantial only by year four. The revenue generation is crucial for the repayment to be done within time, but revenue alone is not sufficient as the profitability would be adversely affected from high printing, distribution and promotional cost. There are interest obligations as well that need to be handled along with principal payment.
It is therefore important for the bank to evaluate projected operating cash flow, interest coverage and debt service coverage ratio.

Security that the bank should request

It is important for the bank to ask for security that protects its exposure in the event of failure of magazine business. The types of guarantee that should be asked are personal guarantee, debenture, equipment security, receivable security and insurance. Personal guarantee along with registered debenture are highly important because a new magazine company would have limited tangible assets.

Review of theory and application of techniques

The important concepts or techniques to consider are the 5C’s of credit which evaluate character, capacity, capital, collateral and conditions before approving the loan to superb magazine Limited. Cash flow forecasting is another important technique which evaluates the possibility of the business to meet printing cost, operating expenses and loan installments. Ratio analysis through also be applied to evaluate liquidity, profitability, gearing and interest coverage using the financial statements of Superb Magazine Limited. The break even analysis techniques should be applied to evaluate the number of magazine copies that need to be sold in order to cover the fixed and variable costs. The working capital management calculation would help in evaluating inventory, retailer receivables and supplier payment periods.

Overall lending decision

The analysis of Superb Magazine Limited indicates that the company shows a good growth potential through national distribution, experience management and advertising partnership, but there is lack of trading history, significant dependence on external investment and uncertainty with respect to cash flows. It is important for the bank to consider conditional approval of the loan provided satisfactory financial forecasts and appropriate security are provided.

Do You Need Full Answer With References?

The analysis of the case scenario of Superb Magazine considering financial risks, funding requirements, repayment capacity and security from a lender’s perspective above indicates the positive as well as negative aspects associated with the business which should be considered by the bank before granting loan. With our accounting assignment help expert in the UK, you can also order a similar kind of accounting case study by visiting our case study writing service page. You can also check the quality of our accounting experts by reviewing the accounting assignment samples or the experts’ written answers from the University of Westminster.

Related answers